{ "sets": { "test_count_fresh": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 600, "pictures": 600, "a": 0.74, "b": 0.7633333333333333, "difference": 0.023333333333333317, "ci95": [ -0.0050000000000000044, 0.05166666666666664 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 600, "pictures": 600, "a": 0.5763476151482702, "b": 0.5738475317419256, "difference": -0.0025000834063445554, "ci95": [ -0.029590039246708333, 0.02324226594506207 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_countbench": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 491, "pictures": 491, "a": 0.1894093686354379, "b": 0.3564154786150713, "difference": 0.1670061099796334, "ci95": [ 0.12830957230142565, 0.20977596741344195 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 491, "pictures": 491, "a": 2.249204785673313, "b": 1.6021778431421219, "difference": -0.647026942531191, "ci95": [ -0.7236271559411285, -0.5697184849200367 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll_warning": false }, "test_vsr": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 904, "pictures": 552, "a": 0.6792035398230089, "b": 0.661504424778761, "difference": -0.017699115044247815, "ci95": [ -0.03871681415929196, 0.003293084522502765 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 904, "pictures": 552, "a": 0.6155330847335275, "b": 0.6197663897233163, "difference": 0.0042333049897888, "ci95": [ -0.008103858831641997, 0.016373944210066993 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": false, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_v7w": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1000, "pictures": 1000, "a": 0.721, "b": 0.721, "difference": 0.0, "ci95": [ -0.017000000000000015, 0.018000000000000016 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1000, "pictures": 1000, "a": 0.6838468317414087, "b": 0.6725771682747884, "difference": -0.011269663466620283, "ci95": [ -0.03041221689888618, 0.007412588911638762 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_pope": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 8676, "pictures": 482, "a": 0.851083448593822, "b": 0.8495850622406639, "difference": -0.001498386353158132, "ci95": [ -0.008529276164130906, 0.005301982480405698 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 8676, "pictures": 482, "a": 0.3702472832864825, "b": 0.36794475743031013, "difference": -0.002302525856172355, "ci95": [ -0.01004565387165457, 0.005636645091598225 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_vqa_yesno": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1000, "pictures": 984, "a": 0.71, "b": 0.704, "difference": -0.006000000000000005, "ci95": [ -0.021956087824351322, 0.01106639839034207 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1000, "pictures": 984, "a": 0.5768279689372598, "b": 0.5741047062190436, "difference": -0.002723262718216213, "ci95": [ -0.012621285357050205, 0.0073198649324632825 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": false, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_vqa_choice": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1420, "pictures": 1346, "a": 0.897887323943662, "b": 0.9091549295774648, "difference": 0.011267605633802802, "ci95": [ 0.0020862308762169546, 0.022487702037948032 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1420, "pictures": 1346, "a": 0.2706275980383607, "b": 0.2705435796140065, "difference": -8.401842435418194e-05, "ci95": [ -0.011447355800969727, 0.011158424151348323 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_gqa": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 992, "pictures": 882, "a": 0.7842741935483871, "b": 0.7903225806451613, "difference": 0.006048387096774133, "ci95": [ -0.011033099297893645, 0.02300000000000002 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 992, "pictures": 882, "a": 0.4089840430444238, "b": 0.4104783294623267, "difference": 0.0014942864179028903, "ci95": [ -0.013564724731577937, 0.016149505199867686 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_exist": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1120, "pictures": 1099, "a": 0.9383928571428571, "b": 0.9473214285714285, "difference": 0.008928571428571397, "ci95": [ -0.000889679715302516, 0.018766756032171594 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1120, "pictures": 1099, "a": 0.16199041568107028, "b": 0.16308653751641133, "difference": 0.0010961218353410518, "ci95": [ -0.012942116093576261, 0.01502907012673671 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_position": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1274, "pictures": 1231, "a": 0.8720565149136578, "b": 0.8846153846153846, "difference": 0.012558869701726816, "ci95": [ -0.0007886435331231345, 0.026025236593059997 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1274, "pictures": 1231, "a": 0.3045267949584121, "b": 0.2882323744865599, "difference": -0.0162944204718522, "ci95": [ -0.03009423881355039, -0.003500244757008719 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_relation": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1950, "pictures": 1453, "a": 0.7107692307692308, "b": 0.7548717948717949, "difference": 0.04410256410256408, "ci95": [ 0.028018339276617454, 0.059034907597535935 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1950, "pictures": 1453, "a": 0.5401162626494179, "b": 0.4896254970901639, "difference": -0.050490765559254025, "ci95": [ -0.061521469864747935, -0.038556349244042165 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_size": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1100, "pictures": 975, "a": 0.86, "b": 0.8718181818181818, "difference": 0.011818181818181839, "ci95": [ -0.0009165902841430373, 0.025711662075298514 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1100, "pictures": 975, "a": 0.35032188023362587, "b": 0.3361044083603172, "difference": -0.014217471873308685, "ci95": [ -0.028957271795469974, 0.0003334966656227678 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_position_flip": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 640, "pictures": 636, "a": 0.85, "b": 0.846875, "difference": -0.0031249999999999334, "ci95": [ -0.021943573667711602, 0.014128728414442682 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 640, "pictures": 636, "a": 0.37288566299069764, "b": 0.35918046542178717, "difference": -0.013705197568910477, "ci95": [ -0.029400569310068958, 0.002968877802506875 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": false, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_relation_flip": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1492, "pictures": 1192, "a": 0.6689008042895442, "b": 0.6977211796246648, "difference": 0.028820375335120607, "ci95": [ 0.009510869565217406, 0.04778156996587024 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1492, "pictures": 1192, "a": 0.585918810016869, "b": 0.5450049355513791, "difference": -0.040913874465489886, "ci95": [ -0.052748318876262856, -0.029602205956100636 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "test_bind_gqa": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1484, "pictures": 967, "a": 0.6785714285714286, "b": 0.6765498652291105, "difference": -0.0020215633423180668, "ci95": [ -0.01720578114246385, 0.013468013468013518 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1484, "pictures": 967, "a": 0.56543531676673, "b": 0.5592760342365289, "difference": -0.006159282530201038, "ci95": [ -0.015578151742373092, 0.0028278953758936742 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_lv_vqav2_yesno": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 4887, "pictures": 2069, "a": 0.724780028647432, "b": 0.7249846531614488, "difference": 0.0002046245140168157, "ci95": [ -0.0075005067909993395, 0.008213984835720334 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 4887, "pictures": 2069, "a": 0.551391599768774, "b": 0.5517217482239184, "difference": 0.0003301484551443412, "ci95": [ -0.004196828299816491, 0.005027468860727358 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_lv_aokvqa": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 1138, "pictures": 1138, "a": 0.6256590509666081, "b": 0.6124780316344464, "difference": -0.013181019332161759, "ci95": [ -0.02899824253075567, 0.002636203866432374 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 1138, "pictures": 1138, "a": 0.9295007201330518, "b": 0.9357389801118688, "difference": 0.006238259978816996, "ci95": [ -0.011132842065626924, 0.023444144517427712 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": false, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_lv_scienceqa": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 2097, "pictures": 2097, "a": 0.7663328564616119, "b": 0.7892226990939437, "difference": 0.022889842632331847, "ci95": [ 0.010968049594659024, 0.03528850739151168 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 2097, "pictures": 2097, "a": 0.505658483494164, "b": 0.4709893216879221, "difference": -0.034669161806241855, "ci95": [ -0.04485873743892388, -0.024565908726882524 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_lv_pope": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 9000, "pictures": 500, "a": 0.8502222222222222, "b": 0.8481111111111111, "difference": -0.0021111111111110636, "ci95": [ -0.008888888888888946, 0.004555555555555535 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 9000, "pictures": 500, "a": 0.37292244276041664, "b": 0.3721321698679672, "difference": -0.0007902728924494284, "ci95": [ -0.008944474453509432, 0.007254876618201789 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "held": true, "proven_worse": false, "nll_warning": false }, "bench_whatsup": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 820, "pictures": 820, "a": 0.2841463414634146, "b": 0.2865853658536585, "difference": 0.0024390243902439046, "ci95": [ -0.01341463414634142, 0.018292682926829285 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 820, "pictures": 820, "a": 1.4723660060388828, "b": 1.4909160791754408, "difference": 0.018550073136557987, "ci95": [ 0.005068862787158679, 0.031356396984290935 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll_warning": false }, "dev_mix": { "accuracy": { "metric": "accuracy", "questions": 5178, "pictures": 3087, "a": 0.753765932792584, "b": 0.7553109308613364, "difference": 0.0015449980687524123, "ci95": [ -0.0056006179992273974, 0.009378663540445475 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll": { "metric": "nll", "questions": 5178, "pictures": 3087, "a": 0.5427544545511686, "b": 0.5446964962906559, "difference": 0.0019420417394873102, "ci95": [ -0.0049800214856609015, 0.00870632376742897 ], "resamples": 2000 }, "nll_warning": false } }, "primary": true, "protection": false, "not_held": [ "test_vsr", "test_vqa_yesno", "test_position_flip", "bench_lv_aokvqa" ], "proven_worse": [], "warnings": [], "candidate": false }